In a league where streaky hitters dominate headlines, it’s the consistent performers who offer bettors the best long-term value. MLB’s statistical leaders in hits aren’t just padding box scores; they’re providing steady, predictable production that translates directly into betting opportunities.

When it comes to MLB batter props, consistency is king, and specific names stand out in 2025 as models of reliability. These players not only deliver at the plate game after game but also excel in categories that sportsbooks frequently feature, such as total hits, multi-hit games, and total bases. 

Let’s break down the most consistent hitters this season and how their performances translate into value on the prop market.

Bo Bichette: The Hit Machine

Bo Bichette has been a cornerstone of the Toronto Blue Jays’ lineup, leading the league in hits for much of the season. His ability to make consistent contact, drive the ball to all fields, and avoid prolonged slumps makes him a dream target for MLB batter props bettors.

• Batting Average: .297+,
• Total Hits (to date): League-leading tally of 148,
• Props to Target: Over 1.5 hits, total bases, and hits+runs+RBIs combos.

Bichette’s game-to-game reliability is reflected in his multi-hit performances. He rarely strings together hitless games, which keeps his over/under hit lines favorable for bettors. Against left-handed pitching, his average jumps even higher, creating even more profitable matchups.

With Toronto’s offense providing ample RBI opportunities, Bichette also benefits from batting in front of sluggers who drive him in, giving additional upside in combined stat props.

Manny Machado: Veteran Consistency

While Manny Machado’s power numbers grab attention, his value in the hits leaderboard underscores his well-rounded offensive game. He’s a master of situational hitting, adept at working counts and capitalizing on mistake pitches.

• Batting Average: Around .300,
• Total Hits (to date): Top five in MLB, hovering near 136,
• Props to Target: Total bases, over 0.5 hits, and RBI props in favorable matchups.

Machado’s consistency stems from his ability to adapt to various pitching styles. He’s equally dangerous against hard-throwing right-handers and crafty lefties, which reduces volatility for prop bettors. His knack for producing in clutch situations makes him especially valuable in single-game prop markets when facing rival National League West teams.

In parks like Coors Field or Chase Field, both known for being hitter-friendly, Machado’s hit and total base props often become near must-play options.

Luis Arraez: The Contact Specialist

Luis Arraez is redefining the art of hitting in an era obsessed with launch angle and home runs. His disciplined approach and elite bat-to-ball skills keep his average consistently among the league’s best.

• Batting Average: .290+ (one of the highest in MLB),
• Total Hits (to date): Fourth in MLB with over 135 hits,
• Props to Target: Over 0.5 hits, multi-hit games, and singles props.

Arraez’s value for bettors lies in his almost uncanny ability to put the ball in play. Even when facing elite pitchers, his strikeout rate remains among the lowest in the league, giving him a higher floor for hit-based props. 

While he may not offer as much power upside for total bases, his frequency of singles and line drives keeps his props highly reliable.

Against teams with below-average defensive efficiency, Arraez becomes an even stronger play, as balls in play are more likely to turn into hits.

Trea Turner: Speed and Contact

Trea Turner is only one ahead of Arraez on the leaderboard, but his game adds a different dynamic: speed. Turner’s ability to turn routine grounders into infield hits and his knack for stretching singles into doubles give him multiple avenues to rack up hits.

• Batting Average: Around .282,
• Total Hits (to date): Over 136 hits, third in MLB,
• Props to Target: Hits+runs+RBIs, stolen base combos, total bases.

Turner’s speed also plays a role in specific prop markets beyond hits. Because he’s a threat to steal once on base, his run-scoring potential is higher than that of many other hitters. This makes him particularly valuable in combined stat props, where his ability to contribute across multiple categories boosts the chances of hitting overs.

Matchups against teams with slow-throwing pitchers or catchers with below-average pop times often give Turner’s props an extra edge.

Aaron Judge: Power and Reliability

Aaron Judge may be best known for his home run power, but his placement among the league leaders in hits underscores his all-around hitting ability. Even in games where he doesn’t leave the yard, Judge contributes with singles, doubles, and deep fly balls that find gaps.

• Batting Average: .337+,
• Total Hits (to date): Top 5 in MLB with over 134 hits,
• Props to Target: Total bases, home run props, hits+runs+RBIs.

Judge’s value in the prop market comes from his power translating into multiple bases per hit. In hitter-friendly parks or against fly-ball pitchers, his total base props often offer substantial value. Because pitchers usually work around him, bettors need to monitor walk rates, but his ability to capitalize on mistake pitches keeps his hit probability high.

In rivalry games or national broadcasts, Judge’s track record of rising to the occasion makes him a popular and often profitable prop pick.

Why Consistency Wins in the Prop Market

While long-shot home run props can provide big payouts, the steady returns from consistent hitters build sustainable betting strategies. Players like Bichette, Machado, Arraez, Turner, and Judge aren’t just statistical leaders; they’re the definition of reliability in a sport defined by variability.

By focusing on hitters with stable contact rates, strong situational performance, and adaptability against different pitchers, bettors can tilt the odds in their favor over the long haul.

MLB Offensive Firepower

The 2025 MLB season is full of offensive firepower, but the most valuable names for prop bettors are the ones who show up every night ready to deliver. 

Bo Bichette’s hit machine consistency, Manny Machado’s veteran adjustments, Luis Arraez’s pure contact, Trea Turner’s speed-infused production, and Aaron Judge’s power-and-contact blend give bettors a range of reliable options in the prop market.

Whether you’re chasing over/under hits, total bases, or multi-stat combos, these players provide the consistency needed to navigate a long season successfully. In a game where even the best hitters fail seven times out of ten, these five stand out as the exceptions – and the best investments for MLB batter props this year.

*Content reflects information available as of 2025/08/13; subject to change.